Compensation and Punishment of Victims and Offenders of Environmental Pollution in Nigeria: Preponderance of Evidence or the Provisions of Extant Laws
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.68050/JAMS.2026.888Keywords:
Environmental Pollution, Victims, Offenders, Compensation, Punishment, EvidenceAbstract
Environmental pollution in Nigeria has become a consistent reality for individuals and communities, particularly in the prone area of Niger-Delta. The cost of environmental pollution is carried by ordinary citizens whose water, farms and health are constantly destroyed. From oil spillage to gas flaring to industrial waste and pipeline sabotage. Compensation is often grossly incommensurate, delayed or denied, and polluters or offenders rarely face adequate punishment for their actions especially on the scale of damage done. This study therefore examines the various extant Nigerian laws on compensation and punishment of victims and offenders through the lens of environmental pollution theories applicable. While Nigeria has robust legal frameworks such as the NESREA Act, NOSDRA Act, PIA, Harmful Waste (Special Criminal Provision) Act, 1999 Constitution among other laws enacted to address environmental pollution, the reality has proven to be different. As such, the study will consider the adequacy or otherwise of these laws with respect to compensation of victims and punishment of offenders in the light of preponderance of evidence. The study concludes with a clarion call that evidential proofs need to be pivotal while granting compensatory reliefs for damage done,over and above provision of extant laws. Hence, specialized tribunals created and penalties aligned with actual harm or Nigerian laws will only remain a paper tiger with all fangs and no fight. The study therefore, recommends several reforms to aid proper penalties, compensation and enforcement of environmental laws.
References
1. A. Njoku, ‘The Polluter Pay Principle in the Context of the Nigerian Legal System’ (2021) <https://coraxfoundation.org>
2. B. A. Osigwe, ‘Evaluating Environmental Pollution and the Problems of Compensation in Nigeria’ African Journal of International Energy and Environmental Law (2023) 7 (1) 140-152
<https://ajieel.com/index.php/a/article/view/55>
3. C. J. Aleru, ‘Ten Sentencing in Environmental Offences in Nigeria: An Overview’ African Journal (2025) 6, 106-121 <https://ajeel.com>
4. CETIM, ‘Cases of Environmental Human Rights Violations by Shell in Nigeria’s Niger-Delta’ 26th Session of Human Right Council, 10 June-27 June, 2024 <https://cetim.ch>
5. E. N. Umezuruike, ‘Evidentiary Inequality and the Proof of Environmental Harm: Lessons from Nigeria’ (SSRN, 09 February 2026) <https://papers.ssrn.com>
6. E. Oamen, and M.I. Anushiem, ‘An Appraisal of the Legal Regime on the Human Right to Compensation for Environmental Pollution in Nigeria’ Energy Law Review, (2014) 1 (4), 34-61 <https://www.open-access.bcu.ac.uk>
7. F. I. Allagoa, ‘Compensation as a Remedy Available to Victims of Environmental Degradation in Nigeria’ (2019) https://www.academia.edu>
8. F. I. Allagoa, ‘Compensation as a Remedy Available to Victims of Environmental Degradation in Nigeria’ (2019) <https://www.academia.edu>
9. J. Kola-Balogun, ‘Legal Aspects of International Environmental Protection, The Nigerian Oil Spill’ (1997) <https://www.mondaq.com>
10. J. Parimala, ‘Deterrent Theory of Punishment Explained’ (2017)
<https://www.scribd.com/document/366814509/Penology>
11. K. Kemper and S. Chadudhuri, ‘Air Pollution: A Silent Killer in Lagos’ (2020)
<https://blogs.worldbank.org > accessed 29 July, 2026; L. Croitoru and J.C. Chang, ‘The Cost of Air Pollution in Lagos (2020) <https://openknowledge.worldbank.org>
12. K. Ruhland, ‘Pollution Crisis: What Is the Polluter Pays Principle and How Can It Be Used in Climate Policy?’ (2024) <https://earth.org>
13. K.F. Akeju and T. Owoeye, ‘Economic Self-Reliance’ in C.T. Oluwadare and I.A. Ajayi and L.B. Ajayi (eds) Nigerian People and Culture (1st edn, Directorate of General Studies 2017)
14. Kunak, Urban Air Pollution: Causes, Impacts and Solutions’ (2026) <https://kunakair.com> accessed 29 July, 2026; Royal Belgium Institute, ‘Air Pollution, Major Concern in Urban Industrialized Areas’ (2026) <https://aeronomie.be>
15. M. Idachaba, et.al, ‘The Legal Framework for the Protection of Environmental Rights in Nigeria’
(2022) <https://www.researchgate.net>
16. Motun, ‘The Legal Framework for the Control of Pollution in the Oil and Gas Sector’ (2020)
<https://motun911.wordpress.com>
17. Research Clue, ‘Environmental Pollution in Nigeria: Issues and Solutions’
<https://nairaproject.com/m/projects/907.html>
18. S.O. Ogunleye and A.O. Jegede, ‘Environmental Problems in Nigeria’ in C.T. Oluwadare and I.A. Ajayi and L.B. Ajayi (eds) Nigerian People and Culture (1st edn, Directorate of General Studies 2017)
19. T. A. Majekodunmi, ‘Nigeria’s Oil Pollution Compensation Framework: Assessing the Impact of the Petroleum Industry Act 2021’ Light Bearers Bar Journal (2026) 2
<https://www.nigerianjournalsonline.org> assessed 25 July, 2026
20. United Nations (Nigeria), ‘Common Country Analysis (2022) <https://nigeria.un.org> accessed 29 July, 2026; Interactive Country Fiches, ‘Pollution’ (UNEP)
<https://dicf.unepgrid.ch/nigeria/pollution#section-states>
21. WHO, ‘Health Effect of Air Pollution: Evidence and Implications: Technical Brief’ (2026)
22. World Bank Group,‘Climate Risk Country Profile: Nigeria’ (2021)
<https://climateknowledgeportal.worldbank.org>
23. Worldometer, ‘Nigeria Population Live’ (2026) <https://worldometers.info>
Downloads
Published
Issue
Section
License
Copyright (c) 2026 Author(s)

This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.
Articles published in the Journal of Advanced Multidisciplinary Studies (JAMS) are licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License (CC BY 4.0), unless otherwise stated. Authors retain copyright of their work and grant JAMS the right of first publication.
